A report names the best hour to send a marketing email. The research covers millions of messages, the chart looks convincing, and someone asks why your team is not following it. Before you rearrange the campaign calendar, check what the research actually establishes.
Knowing how to use email marketing benchmarks means reading beyond the headline. They can give you useful questions, expose weak assumptions and suggest something worth trying. They cannot tell you what your particular audience will do simply by including a very large number on the cover.
The useful question is not whether the report is impressive. It is whether its evidence fits the decision in front of you. Here is how to work that out, using send-time research as an example.
Start with the question the report really answers
“Most emails are sent on Thursday” and “Thursday produces the best results” are different findings. The first describes what senders do. It does not establish whether their choice works well, or whether another day would work better.
Even a chart showing stronger results on Thursday needs interpretation. Perhaps the organisations sending then have more engaged lists, better offers or a different mix of campaigns. The day and the result appear together, but that alone does not show that one caused the other.
Read the methodology, not just the recommendation. Was the research comparing existing campaigns, asking marketers about their habits or deliberately testing alternatives under comparable conditions? Each approach can be useful, but they answer different questions. A popular habit is not a proven advantage.
Check who is represented
Look for the businesses, audiences, countries and campaign types included. An online retailer’s discount emails are not a ready-made reference point for an engineering supplier’s technical newsletter. Both are email marketing; their readers have different reasons to pay attention.
The same applies within a sector. A charity’s emergency appeal, supporter update and volunteer briefing have different purposes. A benchmark that blends them may conceal more than it explains about your planned newsletter.
For a larger organisation, check the geographical mix rather than accepting “global” as a guarantee of relevance. A dataset dominated by one market may tell you little about another. For a smaller business, a focused study of a comparable audience may be more useful than a much larger collection of unrelated campaigns.
Find out what the big number counts
Millions of emails are not necessarily millions of independent decisions. A large sender may contribute many messages, while another contributes only a few. Ask whether the published result gives more weight to high-volume senders or treats every campaign equally.
Neither approach is automatically wrong. They describe different things. A message-weighted result tells you more about the messages in the dataset; a campaign-level comparison tells you more about the campaigns. Without that distinction, a headline can look more representative than it is.
Also check the reporting period and any exclusions. Does a year-round recommendation draw heavily on holiday promotions? Were tiny campaigns, unusually large lists or particular industries removed? These details help you judge the evidence, not disqualify it for failing to resemble your business perfectly.
A popular habit is not a proven advantage.
Compare definitions before comparing performance
“Best” needs an outcome attached. Highest recorded open rate is not the same as most completed purchases, qualified enquiries or donations. Choose the result that matches the job of your email, then check whether the report measures it.
Even familiar labels need checking. A click rate may use unique recipients who clicked or the total number of clicks, including repeat activity. Its denominator may be messages sent or messages delivered. A percentage calculated differently from yours is not a fair target for your team.
Recorded opens also need care. Privacy features can download remote email content without the recipient reading the message. That makes an apparent opening time an unreliable account of when someone paid attention.
For send-time research, check whose clock is being used. An hour in the sender’s account timezone is not necessarily that hour for the recipient. If the method does not say, record the uncertainty rather than filling it with an assumption.
Use competitor emails as observations, not results
Subscribing legitimately to competitors’ public newsletters can show you their visible habits: when messages arrive, what they promise and whether their approach changes around important events. That is useful context, particularly when several organisations appear to make the same choice.
What your inbox cannot show is their conversion rate, targeting rules or commercial success. You may be receiving one version of a campaign, not the version sent to everyone. A regular arrival time can reflect an internal production routine rather than a carefully established performance advantage.
Write “these newsletters arrived on Thursday morning”, not “our successful competitors prove Thursday morning works”. The first is an observation you can defend. The second has acquired rather a lot of confidence on the journey.
Turn the report into a decision note
Before a benchmark becomes a target or a calendar change, keep a short record that another person could follow:
- Decision: what are we considering changing, and for which campaign?
- Evidence: which report, edition and measurement period are we using?
- Fit: how closely do its audiences, campaign types and definitions match ours?
- Limits: what does the report leave unclear or fail to measure?
- Next step: what would we need to learn from our own campaigns before changing the routine?
This is particularly helpful when regional teams report to the same marketing lead. Agreeing definitions prevents one team’s clicks being compared with another team’s repeat clicks, or one market being judged against an irrelevant average.
Once a report has passed those checks, use it to shape a manageable test rather than changing everything at once. The principles in our guide to fair email campaign comparisons are useful here too. The benchmark supplies a reason to investigate, not a result you must reproduce.
Give your next benchmark one useful job
Take the report currently influencing your campaign planning and write the decision note above. If you cannot establish its audience or definitions, do not turn its headline into a team performance target. You can still retain it as a tentative idea.
Good research should make your next decision clearer. Sometimes it earns a place in a test plan. Sometimes it saves you from changing something for the wrong reason. Both are worthwhile results.
The WizEmail Team
